Bayside Bakery has a large selection of freshly baked goodies to take care of your sweet tooth cravings! Try our fresh baked items. Our breads, pies, cakes, and cookies are baked throughout the day to guarantee you receive the freshest items available.

Bakery Department at Bayside Fresh Market, featuring artisanal breads, custom cakes, delicious pastries and more.

Cakes and Pastries

Whether you are searching for a special cake or simply looking for a sweet ending to an everyday meal, Our Bakery offers something for everyone. This is a one of a kind bakery, where the aroma of home-style baking weakens even the strongest will. Our Bakery offers a wide variety of fresh goods daily; gourmet cookies, cakes, cake slices, cheesecakes, cheesecake slices, chocolate eclairs, chocolate tortes, banana bread, and other delicious pastries and cakes that no one can resist including the Deep River “Boozy Cakes” in 5 flavors (Rum, Golden Amaretto, Chocolate Kahlua, Limoncello, and Raspberry White Chocolate.)  and 2 sizes (4” and 9 “).


Bayside offers the freshest, highest quality artisan-style breads. We work with several suppliers that use authentic time-honored techniques to ensure exceptional old-world flavor in each and every bite. Our extensive line of specialty breads and rolls are stocked fresh daily.  Some of our offerings include Sourdough, Viennese, Italian, Tuscan, several Ryes (Black Russian, Marble, Bavarian, Jewish, Sour Rueben), French Style Rolls, Baguettes, and Dinner Rolls.

Bayside Fresh Market’s bakery offers cheesecakes and variety cakes, perfect for birthday parties and holidays.

frozen Cakes

Bayside offers many beautiful and delicious cakes that have been frozen for you to serve at your convenience, including our very popular Variety Cakes and Cheesecakes, featuring four different types of Cake or Cheesecake, which are perfect for gatherings where everyone might appreciate a little something different for desert.

We also offer two types of Carrot Cake (6” and 8”), a Pineapple Upside Down Cake, a Lemon Cake, a Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Torte, and a Black and White Cake, a “Sinfully” White cake perfect for any occasion and easily decorated for any purpose. We also have a Butterfinger inspired cake, a Caramel Turtle and Strawberries & Cream cake. All are delicious and will make any meal a special occasion.

frozen pies

Bayside offers a large selection of delicious Pies including, Lemon Meringue, Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, Key Lime, and, during the fall and winter Holidays, Pumpkin and Pecan Pies.

If you would like to serve one tonight, please call ahead and we’ll set one aside for you. Then it will look like you baked all day when you are ready to serve.”

frozen ice cream cakes

Bayside also has several Ice Cream Cakes, including one decorated to help celebrate the Birthday of someone special!